“Just because it feels bad doesn’t mean it’s good for you.”
My inner critic (and, I suspect, most people’s), consumes about three brain cells. One is to mindlessly parrot the kinds of verbal abuse we endured as children, one is to add writerly keywords to give the illusion of relevance, and the third just punches the feel-bad button over and over to give it emotional weight, which in turn gives the illusion that it’s saying something real. That’s it. There’s no there there. It’s like a tape loop connected to a machine that kicks you in the ass.
Our creative selves, on the other hand, are all about making interesting new stuff and making existing stuff better. Upside dominates. Trying something new and seeing what happens has zero cost because it’s interesting and we get to see what happens. It’s not like I’m going to be taken out and flogged if the rough draft of my next fanfic has a scene that refuses to come together. Not unless I do the flogging myself. And I refuse to be the slave of a tape loop connected to a machine that kicks me in the ass.
So I do a few things to avoid this. The key is to give the Doomy McDoomFace part of me zero respect. Ideas for making stories better are worthy of my attention. My Inner Critic, Inner Whiner, Inner Abuser, and Inner Coward are not. So I make room at the table for my creative self and send the peanut gallery out to the backyard to play quietly while I’m working.
Specific tasks:
- Adopting a deliberate policy of “when in doubt, choose the path of greater courage.” Courage is a skill, one well worth cultivating. Remembering and following this policy will give you plenty of practice, which is just as well, because courage is at least as important as proficiency.
- Dare yourself to do the scary thing. Accepting a dare isn’t about skill or even success, it’s about having the courage to make the attempt. Trying seemingly stupid or doomed things is an essential part of creativity.
- Adopting a deliberate policy of “try it and see what happens.” We spend a lot of time creating and weighing inaccurate predictions (and even waking nightmares) about how an as-yet unwritten scene will turn out, and then dithering over these low-grade hallucinations. Write the scene and you’ll have something real to contemplate. You can always back it out later if it blows up in your face, which it sometimes will, of course. But it’ll often be way better than if you’d given yourself a chance to talk yourself out of it.
- Stop being an imposter. For a lot of us, this involves embracing our beginner’s status. It isn’t possible to be so unskilled that you aren’t a beginner! If you don’t claim to be anything else, you’re the real thing. Obviously. The idea that you’re supposed to write like an expert before you have expertise is as ridiculous with writers as it is with brain surgeons. This is true at all stages. Being a pre-debut novelist implies only that you’ll soon prove to be no worse than the worst novelist who ever had a debut. This is not a high bar!
- Accept that your writing skills are what they are at the moment. It’s the only non-psychotic mindset. Creating is a combination of (a) using the skills you already have to create things that require only these skills, (b) extending your skills so you can create things you couldn’t create before, and (c) doing both at once by building modest extensions into your current projects. No one ever talks about (a), but it’s the key to early results.
- Perfectionism is just failure with extra steps. Knock it off. A story is done when it’s about as good as you can make it with the skills you actually have at the moment. Anything more requires a miracle, an d miracles aren’t your department. Accept this and your work takes a big leap in quality and creativity in addition to being completed. Anyway, humans can’t do perfection except in trivial things. (We’re asked to do a lot of trivial things in the classroom when we’re growing up, so it’s easy to lose track of this, but in the real world, perfectionism amounts to lying down across the railroad tracks of creativity.) Perfection used to be considered to be reserved for the immortal gods; arrogating it to yourself was the sin of hubris. Later, it was relegated to the One God and the sin was that of pride. Now it’s the sins of nitpicking, triviality, incompletion, and failure.
- I keep my Inner Reader by my side when I write revise. I really do: I keep track of how a willing reader is likely to react to the current passage while I’m composing it. I visualize him as my considerably younger self before I became interested in writing. I was always an avid reader and was prepared accept all kinds of stories on their own terms if the author didn’t make this too difficult. My Inner reader never whines or casts blame, but when I stumble he wishes I hadn’t, and also points out opportunities I’ve missed. I’ve never found the whole nitpicky, Negative Nancy/Gloomy Gus/Chicken Little mindset to be of the slightest use. Cheerful people (even imaginary ones) are at least as good at finding blunders and are infinitely better and finding fixes for them.
“Just because it feels bad doesn’t mean it’s good for you.”